Debate heats up over regulation for pace of transition to electrification

With increasing evidence of climate change is it time for the LCV sector to speed up its adoption of battery-powered vehicles?

As the UK notched up its fifth heatwave of the summer in a season of prolonged above-average temperatures and drought, both of which are widely attributed to the effects of climate change, the debate over whether the government should water down its regulation to drive up sales of zero-emission vehicles at the expense of those powered by the internal combustion engine (ICE), has hotted up.

While both the government’s Climate Change Committee (CCC) and lobbyists for the UK’s motor industry concur with the former’s assertion that “electric van sales remain off track”, when it comes to what to do about it their views diverge

The CCC argues the government needs “a more ambitious plan to electrify the UK” with “an accelerated roll out of electric vehicles”.

In contrast to the CCC’s demand for the government to “stand firm behind the ZEV mandate”, the Society of Motor Manufacturers and Traders (SMMT) calls for the upcoming review of the regulation to better reflect customer demand; it forecasts EVs will account for 11.5% of the UK’s LCV market in 2026, less than half of the mandated 24%.

Both the CCC and SMMT agree however, that the government should remove barriers to EV adoption, primarily through increasing access to affordable public charging.

Although the mandate for electric vans calls for a slower uptake than does the regulation for cars, the transition for vans has so far proved to be more problematic.

Tom Riley, founder of Electric Vehicle newsletter, The Fast Charge and a strong advocate for electric vehicle adoption, believes the government is right in setting out a lower trajectory for LCV electrification.

“There has been very generous support provided for the van transition, but it’s not materialised in the same way that incentives for cars have,” he told UKVoty.

“I think it would be idiotic not to have commercial vehicles on an easier path – it’s a completely different audience compared to those getting cars.”

So, is the mandated target for 70% of LCV sales to be electric by 2030 realistic?

“In my opinion, no. I hope I’m wrong, but I think the model choice probably isn’t in the same league as for cars,” said Riley.

“Likewise, the infrastructure is probably behind when it comes to what a van owner needs versus a car driver.”

Vans typically have longer lifecycles than cars and this also slows down the transition to EVs, according to Riley.

“People driving vans or who own a fleet of them simply don’t change vehicles as much as a household with a car does,” he said.

Riley pointed out though, that for operators running vans on well-defined routes with predictable mileages, switching to EVs should be straightforward.

Legacy manufacturers that have historically invested heavily in ICE vehicles are leading the lobby to slow down the mandated transition to electrification, which targets a total ban on petrol and diesel sales by 2035.

Riley says there was initially “a great deal of sympathy” for vehicle makers in the UK “who were clearly having to meet a high bar and innovate” and as a result several amendments were made to the mandate to support manufacturers.

“They have always had Whitehall’s ear, both under the former Conservative and [current] Labour government,” Riley claimed.

Now, however, he suggests manufacturers’ calls for further concessions look like self-interest.

“In any other business segment, if you failed to make a product people wanted, nobody would have much sympathy for you,” he argued.

The question of whether customers want the product is key; Riley believes they do:

“New EV registrations are going up and up. And so are used EV sales. I believe the demand is there, and I know the manufacturers have enough flexibility to make the mandate work.”

Stuart Cunningham, head of Direct Sales at fleet management company Alphabet GB, says LCV manufacturers and fleet managers must educate operators about eLCVs and how they may differ to the diesel-powered models they are used to.

“The onus is on the automotive industry, fleet managers and business leaders to show stakeholders how electric vans can be made to work for them,” said Cunningham.

While the direction of travel towards zero-emission vehicles is widely supported, the speed and path taken to reach this destination is less clear. The journey could take longer for vans than cars, there are fewer electric models to choose from, a lack of confidence they can do the work of diesel alternatives and less opportunity for cheap home charging.

As for manufacturers, the winners will be those that make the best, most capable products.  Brands able to invest all their resources into EVs would appear to have an advantage but on the other hand, legacy manufacturers can tap into a wealth of market experience and product knowledge. The losers will be those that refuse to acknowledge the inevitable shift away from the ICE age to embrace the challenge of electrification.

Share on

Latest News

Vantastec HQ

Industry

Time for food suppliers to get ready for Christmas rush
Foton Tunland coming to UK 2027

Manufacturer

Foton to launch double-cab diesel pick-up in UK
UK VOTY Industry Awards Finalists 2027

Industry

Industry Awards shortlists revealed for UK Van of the Year Awards 2027
Iveco e-Jolly

Manufacturer

Iveco calls for government to tip market balance towards electrification
electric van sales fall short of targets

Manufacturer

Electric van sales hit record high
AFP joint chair James Pestell

Industry

New AFP joint vice chair to promote use of AI
Natalie Manson Alphabet (GB)

Industry

Alphabet (GB) appoints Natalie Manson as regional development manager
AA VOR report

Industry

Downtime puts van operators under pressure, reports AA
Van Guard Black range

Industry

Van Guard launches new range of LCV accessories
Nurture Group

Industry

Nurture Group centralises van conversions with new Mediafleet Supplier Hub
Tim Peacock Fleet Assist

Industry

Fleet Assist creates new position to strengthen leadership team
Gareth Jones CPD

Industry

CPD Group launches Key4E
heavy city traffic

Industry

Fleetcheck urges cooperative approach for traffic management
Rhino invests £5m in L4V

Industry

Rhino pumps £5m into Locks 4 Vans
telematics keyboard operator

Featured

Focus on: Technology and Telematics
AFP paul hollick

Industry

AFP toolkit aims to help companies offer work placements
Delivan L2H3

Manufacturer

Delivan gears up for European launch
Enter Left

Industry

Extra time to enter the UK Van of the Year Industry Awards
Stefan Mecha VWCV ceo dressed as a racing car driver

Manufacturer

VWCV launches Connect Pro
BYD E-Vali rear shot

Manufacturer

BYD showcases E-Vali electric van in Hanover

Related News

UK commercial vehicle production
UK CV production creeps up in June
time is running out
Final weekend to enter the UK Van of the Year Industry Awards
Bott Van Guard van
Bott showcases VanGuard at the CV Show
isuzu-dmax-ev-national-grid-737x433
Isuzu D-Max EV enters National Grid fleet trial
CAP hpi increases EV RVs
CAP hpi raises RV forecasts for electric vans
AA VOR report
Downtime puts van operators under pressure, reports AA
Kia PV5 Coolkit fridge van
Focus on: Conversions
42193-tr0400001pic-new-plate-rt
Volkswagen opens order books for first plug-in hybrid Transporter
Farizon partners with Europcar
Farizon selects Europcar to provide van replacement service
merc-boulder-707x433
Mercedes-Benz reveals new van architecture
Scroll to Top